Solved

Returning customer - cannot register against old account

  • 11 August 2020
  • 34 replies
  • 1255 views


Show first post

34 replies

Userlevel 8
Badge +9

Thanks. Then they lose custom. End of. And I will send an email asking them to remove my details because they shouldn’t just be holding peoples data for the hell of it. 

Perhaps iD have a legitimate reason for keeping your iD account details, in order to comply with financial industry rules (FCA) for credit, and HMRC rules around VAT, etcetera.

So I pose a security risk. 
someone sets up a random email address which they have no intention to use other than creating an account on idmobile. It doesn’t get used and the provider closes the email account down due to inactivity. Someone else takes out the same email address. The original person wants to log on but can’t remember their password. Password resets gets sent to the email address now in control by another party. They now have full access to your account and can happily start purchasing phones. 
Asking customers to randomly create an email address just for a login to their account simply goes against any kind of cyber security concepts.

This is just one of many reasons I don’t want to create a random email address. 

Again doesn’t solve the issue. I would like my previous details removed from the system so I can re-register using the same email address. I don’t need the inconvenience of having to use a different email address. 
And as previous stated you need to enter the mobile number first with your name and it then fails. I assume because it recognises the mobile number is assigned to the first account. 
It’s ok though. I’ll just find another provider if idmobile systems are incapable of being updated to allow returning customers. 

I don’t think your mobile number being linked to two different iD accounts is an issue @Mark J Colly
I joined iD Mobile, then left, then rejoined, and on both occasions used the same mobile number with my different iD accounts online. 

Unfortunately @Mark J Colly, iD Mobile can’t or won’t delete an old iD account from their systems. If you want to manage your iD account online, you’ll need to reregister, using a different email address. 

If you’ve got an Android phone you could use the Gmail address in a different format, for example the following are all treated as one mailbox with Google Mail:

If you haven’t got a Gmail address, your email service provider might allow you to create an alias for your mailbox. You can do this with an outlook.com mailbox.

 

Initially I don’t want idmobile to delete my account. I want to retain it even with the old contract details. I just want my current contract added to my account. I just can’t get my head around how a modern MVNO cannot do something as basic as this. It will mean the data they do hold on account members is more accurate should they need it for a one their ‘legal’ requirements. Rather than having duplicate accounts for the same person, yet wait for it, they won’t know it is the same person if there is a different address etc!!

Userlevel 8
Badge +9

Initially I don’t want idmobile to delete my account. I want to retain it even with the old contract details. I just want my current contract added to my account. I just can’t get my head around how a modern MVNO cannot do something as basic as this. It will mean the data they do hold on account members is more accurate should they need it for a one their ‘legal’ requirements. Rather than having duplicate accounts for the same person, yet wait for it, they won’t know it is the same person if there is a different address etc!!

 

I agree @Mark J Colly, it seems crazy but currently each iD account online requires a unique email address (username), and each iD account online can only be linked to one connection (SIM card contract).
I know of several other UK service providers whose systems don’t have these limitations, but it appears iD Mobile don’t intend to change their systems, and might have reasons for not changing things.
 

So I pose a security risk. 
someone sets up a random email address which they have no intention to use other than creating an account on idmobile. It doesn’t get used and the provider closes the email account down due to inactivity. Someone else takes out the same email address. The original person wants to log on but can’t remember their password. Password resets gets sent to the email address now in control by another party. They now have full access to your account and can happily start purchasing phones. 
Asking customers to randomly create an email address just for a login to their account simply goes against any kind of cyber security concepts.

This is just one of many reasons I don’t want to create a random email address. 

Perhaps this explains why email service providers now encourage customers to use two factor authentication for login. 

Not sure what is meant by “… create a random email address.”

 

Userlevel 7
Badge +4

Hi @Mark J Colly 

 

As we’ve mentioned a new iD Mobile account would require a new iD Mobile app/website account too, you’ll need to register again if you’ve left and then come back to us later.

 

If you’d like to submit a subject access request, I’d recommend the following link;

 

https://privacyportal-de.onetrust.com/webform/fcbd696d-c14f-408d-b001-5765158c26f8/857a80ef-f496-40e2-adcb-91c40f492f50

 

Tom

Just wondering how I get rid of old account from 2016 as when I log in on new one it keeps taking me to the old one

Userlevel 8
Badge +9

Just wondering how I get rid of old account from 2016 as when I log in on new one it keeps taking me to the old one

You’ll need to reregister to link your new iD contract with an online iD account @John Pitchford, which means you’ll need a new username (email address) to regregister.

Unfortunately, this is a limitation of systems used by iD Mobile system, meaning a unique username is needed for each online iD account, and an online account cannot be linked to multiple iD contracts.

 

Replying here in case more voices are needed to get something done about this

I encountered this issue (among others), as I was going to leave ID Mobile for a better plan, and then a salesperson recommended a plan that was cheaper. However, they had failed to mention that it was an entirely new contract - so to keep my number (due to another issue with not allowing internal porting) I had to leave ID Mobile and re-transfer my number.

I tried using a +alias for my screen name/username/login email. However, the registration form will not accept this. The only thing that was possible was using dots, as Google strangely enough ignores them (https://gmail.googleblog.com/2008/03/2-hidden-ways-to-get-more-from-your.html) - but this is not universal to all email providers and so it should not be the fix ID Mobile relies on.

So with all due respect ID Mobile, expecting customers to either create random email mailboxes (especially when these aliassing solutions are not universal) or use fake emails is not a good solution. Besides the inconveniece (especially in the case of a separate mailbox), it poses quite a risks as @Mark J Colly and others have outlined.

It’s an issue that has clearly been present for years based on when this forum topic was opened, and also others, and it has affected a number of customers. A simple fix would be to de-couple usernames and email addresses, so while the same contact email can be used (which is already allowed), usernames would not be email addresses. It appears that your accounting system already does this - since we are allowed to change email addresses afterwards, so it’s an issue that’s present in the registration process only. This way we can create a new username without such an issue for email addresses. As @andewhite pointed out, other providers don’t have this issue. 

Userlevel 7
Badge +7

Hi @Mark Said Camilleri,

Welcome to the Community!

Firstly in regards to the new contract being sold to you we can look into this and pass on any feedback to the relevant team for investigation.

Unfortunately the only current solution for registering another account is another email address being required. 

However I can assure you that the team are looking at the re-registration process and customers being able to use the same email address again. Unfortunately at the moment we don’t have a timescale but it is being worked on and will be rolled out in the future.

I can understand that it may be an inconvenience to create another email for the account, however this would be the only solution if you wish to register another iD Mobile account.


Kash

Reply


Why iD Mobile?