Skip to main content
Question

Severe network issues


I switched to iD on 30/11/22 from a Smarty contract. The signal in my flat was okay for two or so days and had been fine to great in the years Id been with Smarty. 

After two days my network speed dropped significantly with both Smarty and iD (both powered by Three. my contract hadnt expired with smarty so I have been testing its speed against iD every few days) and now averages under 1mb/s. Even light browsing such as getting to the appropriate page to list an issue has taken some time. I use my mobile data in lieu of WiFi for my home, hence getting an unlimited data plan.

I have contacted Smarty who state there are no issues in my area, and have tried contacting three who say they cannot/will not help with this issue as I am not a Three customer. 

There have been no adjustments to the building I am in and I am situated on the top floor of a 3 floor building in a small town centre. signal is fine outside of my postcode.

the signal issues run the same across a new samsung galaxy s22 (came with the contract), my old Huawei mate 20 pro and a Huawei mifi hub. same issue across both huawei simcards and the iD sim card. each sim card has been tested in each device at least once.

I have checked iD and Threes network checker functions and both say there are no issues in my area, though in a phone call to iD a few weeks ago (prior to the conversation they denied any issues) it was stated there wereajor issues with a mast in my area.

I have been struggling to get in touch with Smarty as it was not made clear that the account for posing queries is separate to the main ID account - which as you can imagine has caused some frustration (more on this on another post).

 

What I want is to know why my signal is this poor and how it can be fixed. If a member of staff could please contact me I will provide the postcode/address I am situated at.

 

This topic has been closed for replies.

16 replies

andewhite
Platinum 
Contributor
Forum|alt.badge.img+26
  • Platinum 
Contributor
  • 12403 replies
  • December 19, 2022

  • Author
  • Active Contributor
  • 10 replies
  • December 19, 2022
andewhite wrote:

cheers for the proffer but ive already been checking this - it says everything is fine, when it isnt aha.


andewhite
Platinum 
Contributor
Forum|alt.badge.img+26
  • Platinum 
Contributor
  • 12403 replies
  • December 19, 2022

Do you still have a SMARTY plan?

What does SMARTY’s web chat team say?

I’ve often needed to make a complaint to SMARTY, via web chat, in order to get a sensible response from the complaints team (who are UK based).

SMARTY’s offshore web chat team often offer scripted responses, and do not always seem to read, nor understand question/s.


  • Author
  • Active Contributor
  • 10 replies
  • December 19, 2022
andewhite wrote:

Do you still have a SMARTY plan?

What does SMARTY’s web chat team say?

I’ve often needed to make a complaint to SMARTY, via web chat, in order to get a sensible response from the complaints team (who are UK based).

SMARTY’s offshore web chat team often offer scripted responses, and do not always seem to read, nor understand question/s.

aye I haven't cancelled it yet incase iD turn put to be untenable as an option.

Smarty, in my last chat with them, stated that as the speed check I showed them at the time was 2mb/s that the speed was in acceptable ranges and nothing needed to be done. Ill definitely try raising a complaint with them (I thought their web chat /was/ the complaints line oops). Hopefully iD will get in touch via this or Ill have to issue a complaint with them also. Cheers again for the help c:


andewhite
Platinum 
Contributor
Forum|alt.badge.img+26
  • Platinum 
Contributor
  • 12403 replies
  • December 19, 2022

Your Galaxy S22 Ultra is a 5G capable handset - 2MB/s download on 5G doesn’t sound acceptable to me.

It could be Three UK are currently decommissioning the 3G network in your area, which they’re doing UK wide, and aim to complete the task by end of 2024. While that happens the local network performance might be degraded.

From Jan 2025, the Three UK mobile network will be 4G and 5G only.

https://help.smarty.co.uk/en/articles/6142278-switching-off-3g

 

 

 


Tom
iD Mobile Employee
Forum|alt.badge.img+25
  • iD Mobile Employee
  • 8408 replies
  • December 20, 2022

Hi @Mr Barnaby Fryer 

 

Sorry to hear you’ve been having issues in your area with the signal, if you’ve been having issues across multiple SIMs from different networks (that use the same host network) it sounds like that Three UK are having an outage in your area, since you were having good signal and then it’s suddenly dropped, when did you first notice these issues?

 

The Three outage checker should pick up and report any outages that they’re aware of and working on.

 

Tom


  • Author
  • Active Contributor
  • 10 replies
  • December 21, 2022
Tom wrote:

Hi @Mr Barnaby Fryer 

 

Sorry to hear you’ve been having issues in your area with the signal, if you’ve been having issues across multiple SIMs from different networks (that use the same host network) it sounds like that Three UK are having an outage in your area, since you were having good signal and then it’s suddenly dropped, when did you first notice these issues?

 

The Three outage checker should pick up and report any outages that they’re aware of and working on.

 

Tom

issues began around 30/11/22 with some degradation of quality prior.

 

the Three outage checker consistently states there are no issues - despite it having been announced by Smarty twice now. Are you able to confirm whether there is a damaged mast in my area, and if so, proffer any solutions/recompense?


  • Author
  • Active Contributor
  • 10 replies
  • December 21, 2022
Mr Barnaby Fryer wrote:

I switched to iD on 30/11/22 from a Smarty contract. The signal in my flat was okay for two or so days and had been fine to great in the years Id been with Smarty. 

After two days my network speed dropped significantly with both Smarty and iD (both powered by Three. my contract hadnt expired with smarty so I have been testing its speed against iD every few days) and now averages under 1mb/s. Even light browsing such as getting to the appropriate page to list an issue has taken some time. I use my mobile data in lieu of WiFi for my home, hence getting an unlimited data plan.

I have contacted Smarty who state there are no issues in my area, and have tried contacting three who say they cannot/will not help with this issue as I am not a Three customer. 

There have been no adjustments to the building I am in and I am situated on the top floor of a 3 floor building in a small town centre. signal is fine outside of my postcode.

the signal issues run the same across a new samsung galaxy s22 (came with the contract), my old Huawei mate 20 pro and a Huawei mifi hub. same issue across both huawei simcards and the iD sim card. each sim card has been tested in each device at least once.

I have checked iD and Threes network checker functions and both say there are no issues in my area, though in a phone call to iD a few weeks ago (prior to the conversation they denied any issues) it was stated there wereajor issues with a mast in my area.

I have been struggling to get in touch with Smarty as it was not made clear that the account for posing queries is separate to the main ID account - which as you can imagine has caused some frustration (more on this on another post).

 

What I want is to know why my signal is this poor and how it can be fixed. If a member of staff could please contact me I will provide the postcode/address I am situated at.

 

Mr Barnaby Fryer wrote:

I switched to iD on 30/11/22 from a Smarty contract. The signal in my flat was okay for two or so days and had been fine to great in the years Id been with Smarty. 

After two days my network speed dropped significantly with both Smarty and iD (both powered by Three. my contract hadnt expired with smarty so I have been testing its speed against iD every few days) and now averages under 1mb/s. Even light browsing such as getting to the appropriate page to list an issue has taken some time. I use my mobile data in lieu of WiFi for my home, hence getting an unlimited data plan.

I have contacted Smarty who state there are no issues in my area, and have tried contacting three who say they cannot/will not help with this issue as I am not a Three customer. 

There have been no adjustments to the building I am in and I am situated on the top floor of a 3 floor building in a small town centre. signal is fine outside of my postcode.

the signal issues run the same across a new samsung galaxy s22 (came with the contract), my old Huawei mate 20 pro and a Huawei mifi hub. same issue across both huawei simcards and the iD sim card. each sim card has been tested in each device at least once.

I have checked iD and Threes network checker functions and both say there are no issues in my area, though in a phone call to iD a few weeks ago (prior to the conversation they denied any issues) it was stated there wereajor issues with a mast in my area.

I have been struggling to get in touch with Smarty as it was not made clear that the account for posing queries is separate to the main ID account - which as you can imagine has caused some frustration (more on this on another post).

 

What I want is to know why my signal is this poor and how it can be fixed. If a member of staff could please contact me I will provide the postcode/address I am situated at.

 

edit: I mixed up smarty and iD on the original post. it was smarty who I called and informed me of mast issues, and iD was who I was struggling to access the customer services of.

 

also a further update: a chat with smarty on 20/12/22 informed me again that there is a damaged mast in the area but would not explain why other members of staff at the same rank were stating otherwise.


  • Author
  • Active Contributor
  • 10 replies
  • December 21, 2022
andewhite wrote:

Your Galaxy S22 Ultra is a 5G capable handset - 2MB/s download on 5G doesn’t sound acceptable to me.

It could be Three UK are currently decommissioning the 3G network in your area, which they’re doing UK wide, and aim to complete the task by end of 2024. While that happens the local network performance might be degraded.

From Jan 2025, the Three UK mobile network will be 4G and 5G only.

https://help.smarty.co.uk/en/articles/6142278-switching-off-3g

 

 

 

ill have a look into this, cheers


andewhite
Platinum 
Contributor
Forum|alt.badge.img+26
  • Platinum 
Contributor
  • 12403 replies
  • December 21, 2022

iD Mobile and SMARTY are completely independent companies.

The only thing they’ve got in common is that both use Three UK’s mobile network infrastructure to deliver their services.

In my experience, iD Mobile do seem to struggle providing meaningful technical and operational information about the network infrastructure they use.

 


  • Author
  • Active Contributor
  • 10 replies
  • December 23, 2022
Tom wrote:

Hi @Mr Barnaby Fryer 

 

Sorry to hear you’ve been having issues in your area with the signal, if you’ve been having issues across multiple SIMs from different networks (that use the same host network) it sounds like that Three UK are having an outage in your area, since you were having good signal and then it’s suddenly dropped, when did you first notice these issues?

 

The Three outage checker should pick up and report any outages that they’re aware of and working on.

 

Tom

Hi Tom, any update?  feel like Im being left in the dark here


Kash
iD Mobile Employee
Forum|alt.badge.img+24
  • iD Mobile Employee
  • 8193 replies
  • December 26, 2022

@Mr Barnaby Fryer,

Please could you confirm your postcode for us and we can take a look into this?

 

Kash


  • Author
  • Active Contributor
  • 10 replies
  • December 28, 2022
Kash wrote:

@Mr Barnaby Fryer,

Please could you confirm your postcode for us and we can take a look into this?

 

Kash

OL14 5EZ, as stated multiple times in prior replies to this thread


Mohammed
iD Mobile Employee
  • iD Mobile Employee
  • 7962 replies
  • December 29, 2022

Hello @Mr Barnaby Fryer,

Checking since, the Three Service Checker isn’t reporting any issues now: https://www.three.co.uk/support/network_and_coverage/network_support

Can you advise if you are still having issues with this?

 

Mohammed

 


  • Author
  • Active Contributor
  • 10 replies
  • December 29, 2022
Mohammed wrote:

Hello @Mr Barnaby Fryer,

Checking since, the Three Service Checker isn’t reporting any issues now: https://www.three.co.uk/support/network_and_coverage/network_support

Can you advise if you are still having issues with this?

 

Mohammed

 

signal seems to be at a useable level as of yesterday afternoon - but I still feel the need for some form of recompense for the 3 and a bit weeks wherein I had no useable internet at home


Tom
iD Mobile Employee
Forum|alt.badge.img+25
  • iD Mobile Employee
  • 8408 replies
  • December 30, 2022

Hi @Mr Barnaby Fryer 

 

Glad to hear your signal is back up and running, we’ll shortly send you a Private Message to your Community account, so we can discuss your issue further. 

 

To access your messages, click your profile picture in the top right hand corner and then click ‘Private Messages’. 

 

Alternatively, if you are currently logged in, you can use the following link: https://community.idmobile.co.uk/inbox/overview  

 

We’ll see you there.

 

Tom